May 27, 2022
|
|
|
This paper examines the role that the type of defense
counsel plays in federal justice system outcomes. The
authors begin with a background on federal indigent
defense systems and a review of the prior research
examining the impact of counsel type on sentencing. The
authors then describe the study and present descriptive
results, which explore the frequency and variation in the
use of each type of defense counsel (public defenders,
assigned counsel, and private attorneys) and other key
variables (disposition, incarceration decision, sentence
length, year, district, case, and defendant
characteristics). The authors model the outcomes of
incarceration and sentence length to test whether type of
counsel significantly impacts these decisions after
controlling for legal and extra-legal factors. The results
indicate that defendants who utilize federal public
defenders had higher rates of accepting a plea deal than
those who were provided a Criminal Justice Act panel
attorney or who retained a private attorney. The enactment
of the Criminal Justice Act of 1964 charged the federal
district courts with providing indigent defense services.
Today, there are 81 federal defender organizations,
including federal public defender offices and community
defender organizations. However, the findings also
indicate that individuals represented by Criminal Justice
Act panel attorneys and private counsel have 18-25%
greater odds of being sent to prison once convicted than
those represented by a federal public defender, after
controlling for numerous legal and extra-legal factors.
These findings indicate that federal public defenders may
be more likely to encourage their clients to take plea
deals but may also secure their clients favorable
sentencing outcomes.
|
|
Source: Urban Institute
|
|
On any given day in the United States, more than half a
million people who have not been convicted of any crime
are held in local jails. Most are held because, following
their arrest, they could not afford to pay the bail amount
set as a condition of their release. The negative
consequences of pretrial detention can extend beyond a
short-term jail stay and include an increased likelihood
of receiving a conviction (as opposed to a dismissal);
longer sentences; and an increased chance the individuals
will lose their jobs, homes, and custody of their
children. Despite a growing body of evidence showing that
substantial increases in pretrial release do not pose a
threat to public safety, communities spend about $14
billion each year to incarcerate people who have not been
convicted of crimes. The article looks at reforms in New
Jersey, Illinois, Pennsylvania, and New York, where
research suggests that reforms that focus on restructuring
pretrial policy to strengthen the presumption of release
have positive results like reducing jail populations, and
no major ill effects on court appearance or public safety.
|
|
Source: MDRC
|
|
|
The federal Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) encourages
states and school districts to support students’
transitions from one level of schooling to the next to
reduce the risk of their dropping out. This report
presents findings from recent national surveys, which
suggest that most states and school districts are
providing some types of transition and dropout prevention
services, such as individualized career plans to help
students identify and work toward their long-term goals
and course offerings to help students who have fallen
behind get back on track for graduation. However, many
fewer states and districts have early warning systems
designed to proactively identify the students most at-risk
and in need of services and target such services.
|
|
Source: National Center for Education Evaluation
|
|
Low-skilled adults in literacy in English are those with
skills insufficient to complete tasks requiring comparing
and contrasting information, paraphrasing, or making
low-level inferences. Low-skilled adults in numeracy in
English are those who would have difficulty making
calculations with whole numbers and percentages,
estimating numbers or quantity, and interpreting simple
statistics in text or tables. The results in this report
are presented as the number and percentage of adults at
the Program for the International Assessment of Adult
Competencies (PIAAC) literacy or numeracy proficiency
levels. The PIAAC has five literacy and five numeracy
proficiency levels: from below Level 1 to Level 5. These
levels are described in terms of the types of tasks that
adults are likely to complete successfully at a particular
level. Between 2012/2014 and 2017, the overall percentages
of U.S. adults with low skills did not change
significantly in literacy (21% in 2012/2014; 23% in 2017)
or numeracy (30% in 2012/2014; 33% in 2017). The same was
true for the percentages of adults at Level 1 or at below
Level 1. However, the percentage of adults who could not
participate in the assessment increased from 4% in
2012/2014 to 5% in 2017. The percentage of adults with a
language barrier as the reason for nonparticipation grew
from 3% in 2012/2014 to 4% in 2017, while the percentage
of adults with a cognitive or physical inability as the
reason for non-participation, at about 1%, did not differ
significantly between the years.
|
|
Source: National Center for Education Statistics, U.S.
Department of Education
|
|
When students struggle with the foundational math skills
taught in the early elementary grades, they are likely to
continue to struggle well into middle and high school.
Mathematics knowledge is highly cumulative in nature,
meaning that the ability to master each new concept is
highly dependent upon having mastered the content that
came before. Skill by skill. Grade by grade. As early as
in kindergarten, the role of teachers in building and
cementing these math skills is all-important.
Unfortunately, many elementary teachers do not themselves
feel adequately confident of their own basic math skills.
Potentially lacking confidence or sufficient content
knowledge, they may dedicate less time to teaching math
than students need, unsure of how to help their students
avoid common misconceptions and errors. Compounding the
issue, a basic problem for years has been the assumption
that anyone who has graduated from high school has all the
knowledge they need to teach elementary math. However,
teaching elementary math requires a conceptual
understanding of foundational mathematics and pedagogical
knowledge, neither of which is addressed in a general
mathematics course. Preparation programs must dedicate
sufficient time to both. While weak math instruction in
elementary schools is not a new problem, learning loss as
a result of the COVID-19 pandemic brings new urgency to
this issue. Multiple studies find that elementary
students, already well behind their peers in other
nations, lost more learning in math than in reading during
the pandemic. Programs that earned an A or A+ in 2022 add
the most amount of new credit hours (2.3 credits on
average), they also dedicated most of this additional time
to much neglected math content, as opposed to math
pedagogy, the area in which preparation programs had
already been dedicating sufficient time. Conversely, while
programs earning an F in 2022 also slightly raised the
total time allocated to mathematics preparation (in their
case, an increase of 0.5 credit hours), they tended to
allocate their additional time to math pedagogy. In fact,
F-rated programs, on average, actually reduced the number
of credits dedicated to teaching mathematics content from
1.9 credits in 2014 to 1.6 credits in 2022, a 16% reduction.
|
|
Source: National Council on Teacher Quality
|
|
|
State and local government tax revenues from major
sources—personal income, corporate income, sales, and
property taxes—increased 13% in nominal terms and 6.7% in
inflation-adjusted terms in the fourth quarter of 2021
compared with the same quarter in 2020. State and local
government tax revenues increased 11.7% in real terms when
compared with the fourth quarter in 2019.
Inflation-adjusted state government tax revenues from
major sources increased 18.9% in the fourth quarter of
2021 compared with the same quarter in 2020 and 25.7%
compared with the same period in 2019. Because the global
pandemic and individual, business, and government
responses had an unprecedented impact on state budgets,
including shifting revenues between quarters and fiscal
years, the authors also present the revenue picture for
the second through fourth quarters of 2021 combined
compared with the previous year. State government tax
revenues from major sources increased 20.5% in real terms
for the second through fourth quarters of 2021 combined,
compared with the same period in 2020. Economic factors
that drive revenue growth were strong in the fourth
quarter of 2021 compared with the same quarter in 2020.
State economic performance plummeted early in the pandemic
as governments, businesses, and individuals took actions
to curtail the spread of the virus across the nation. The
pandemic had a very uneven impact on various sectors of
the economy, which has translated into very different
effects across different jobs and places. These patterns
continued to fluctuate in the fourth quarter of 2021 as
different regions experienced different ebbs and flows in
cases and hospitalizations because of variants of SARS-CoV-2.
|
|
Source: Urban Institute
|
|
Since 2007, the National Health Interview Survey Early
Release Program has regularly released preliminary
estimates of the percentages of adults and children living
in homes with only wireless telephones (also known as
cellular telephones, cell phones, or mobile phones). These
estimates are the most up-to-date estimates available from
the federal government concerning the size and
characteristics of this population. Estimates in this
report are based on the second six months of 2021. During
this time period, 68.7% of adults and 79.1% of children
lived in wireless-only households. More than four in five
adults aged 25–29 (87.4%) and aged 30-34 (86.4%) were
wireless-only. The percentage of adults who were
wireless-only decreased as age increased beyond 35 years:
79.6% for those 35–44; 66.2% for those 45–64; and 43.4%
for those 65 and over. Hispanic adults (79.1%) were more
likely than non-Hispanic White (65.6%), non-Hispanic Black
(65.0%), or non-Hispanic Asian (67.2%) adults to be
wireless-only. Men (69.1%) were more likely than women
(66.9%) to be wireless-only. Adults living in the midwest
(69.9%), south (72.5%), and west (69.6%) were more likely
than those living in the northeast (53.6%) to be
wireless-only. Four in five adults living in rented homes
(82.0%) were wireless-only. This percentage is higher than
the percentage for adults living in homes owned by a
household member (61.5%).
|
|
Source: National Center for Health Statistics, U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services
|
|
Popular discussion commonly presumes an outsized role for
minimum wage increases as a driver of wage increases for
minimum wage workers. In this paper, the authors
investigate the accuracy of this presumption using data
from the earnings studies of the Current Population Survey
(CPS). The CPS wage and earnings data enable the authors
to assess the fraction of minimum wage workers who receive
a raise within 12 months of their initial appearance as a
minimum wage worker. On average from 2010 to 2019, the
authors find that roughly 75% of minimum wage workers who
remain employed experience a wage increase within 12
months. This fraction is higher during the later years of
the sample, when the labor market has been strong, than in
the earlier years. The fraction of minimum wage workers
receiving wage increases is moderately higher when states
enact minimum wage increases than when they do not. The
authors also find that the fraction of minimum wage
workers receiving wage increases is correlated with
several measures of labor market tightness. Finally, wage
gains are quite commonly associated with industry and/or
occupation switches. This highlights the importance of
career progression for the growth of earnings among
entry-level workers. The vast majority of the wage gains
realized by minimum wage workers thus appear to be driven
by career progression and increases in labor demand.
Minimum wage increases play a modest role as a driver of
earnings trajectories beyond shaping the initial,
typically short-lived, minimum wage job itself.
|
|
Source: National Bureau of Economic Research
|
|
|
Predictive analytics, or the use of historical data to
forecast future outcomes, has long been a feature of
business and marketing research. But increasingly,
predictive analytics is being applied in the social
service and education domains. Program administrators can
use relatively simple approaches, such as models with a
limited number of measures, to predict outcomes of
interest. Or they may consider more complex
machine-learning models, taking advantage of the large
amounts of data that organizations often collect, to
improve their ability to make predictions. Either way, the
promise of predictive analytics is to help programs
identify those clients who could most benefit from
targeted interventions—facilitating effective service
delivery at an efficient cost. While it was possible to
create predictive models that performed better than random
chance with the data collected by a home visiting program
at intake, these models made numerous mistakes, and, the
models were unable to sufficiently pinpoint the families
at risk while limiting extra expenditures on families not
at risk.
|
|
Source: MDRC
|
|
Suicidal thoughts and behaviors are important public
health concerns in the United States. In 2019, suicide was
the 10th leading cause of death among persons aged ≥18
years (adults); in that year, 45,861 adults died as a
result of suicide, and an estimated 381,295 adults visited
hospital emergency departments for nonfatal,
self-inflicted injuries. Regional- and state-level data on
self-inflicted injuries are needed to help localities
establish priorities and evaluate the effectiveness of
suicide prevention strategies. During 2015–2019, an
estimated 10.6 million (annual average) adults in the
United States (4.3% of the adult population) reported
having had suicidal thoughts during the preceding year.
The findings in this report highlight differences in the
adult prevalence of suicidal thoughts, plans to attempt
suicide, and attempted suicide during the 12 months
preceding the survey at the national, regional, and state
levels during 2015–2019. Geographic differences in
suicidal thoughts and behavior varied by sociodemographic
characteristics and might be attributable to
sociodemographic composition of the population, selective
migration, or the local cultural milieu. These findings
underscore the importance of ongoing surveillance to
collect locally relevant data on which to base prevention
and intervention strategies. Understanding the patterns of
and risk factors for suicide is essential for designing,
implementing, and evaluating public health programs for
suicide prevention and policies that reduce morbidity and
mortality related to suicidal thoughts and behaviors.
State health departments and federal agencies can use the
results from this report to assess progress toward
achieving national and state health objectives in suicide
prevention. Strategies might include identifying and
supporting persons at risk, promoting connectedness, and
creating protective environments.
|
|
Source: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
|
|
Over the last decade, the National Survey of Residential
Care Facilities (NSRCF) and multiple waves of the National
Study of Long-Term Care Providers (NSLTCP) (renamed
National Post-acute and Long-term Care Study in 2020) have
collected data about residential care communities. This
report provides a review of residential care community
eligibility rates over survey years and describes design
differences and methodological changes—including minor
wording changes to screener questions and placement of
question-specific instructions—that may be related to
observed differences in eligibility rates. The NSRCF and
the residential care component of NSLTCP collected data on
residential care providers and their service users. The
residential care sector includes settings such as assisted
living facilities, residential care homes, personal care
homes, residential care facilities, and adult family
homes. Over the survey years, eligibility rates have
varied overall as well as by bed size and mode of survey.
The 2012 wave presented the lowest eligibility rate among
all survey years. Eligibility rates increased when
modifications were made based on respondent comments,
field staff observations, and cognitive testing.
Differences in eligibility rates have an impact on the
estimated size of the residential care sector.
|
|
Source: National Center for Health Statistics
|
N O T E : An online subscription may be required to view some items.
|
|
OPPAGA is currently accepting applications for a part-time, academic year
Graduate Student Position.
OPPAGA is an ideal setting for gaining hands-on experience in policy analysis
and working on a wide range of issues of interest to the Florida Legislature.
OPPAGA provides an opportunity to work in a legislative policy research offices
with a highly qualified, multidisciplinary staff that includes public administrators,
social scientists, accountants, MBA graduates, and others.
|
|
|
|
|
Government Program Summaries (GPS) is a free resource for legislators and the public that provides descriptive information on over 200 state government programs. To provide fiscal data, GPS links to Transparency
Florida, the Legislature's website that includes continually updated information on the state's operating budget and daily expenditures by state agencies.
|
A publication of the Florida Legislature's Office of Program Policy Analysis & Government Accountability
PolicyNotes, published every Friday, features reports, articles, and websites with timely information of interest to policymakers and researchers. Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations
expressed by third parties as reported in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect OPPAGA's views.
Permission is granted to make and distribute verbatim copies of
PolicyNotes provided that this section is preserved on all copies.
|