|
June 30, 2023
|
|
|
This report provides an analysis of serious juvenile
offenses that are not processed through Florida’s court
system to disposition. It examines referrals, which are
similar to an arrest in the adult criminal justice system,
that included at least one felony, violent felony, or
firearm felony to determine whether all charges on the
referral were non-filed (no charges were formally filed)
or nolle prosequi (after the filing, the State Attorney’s
Office decided to no longer pursue the case). Not all
cases are suitable for prosecution, as there may be
problems obtaining evidence or witness statements.
Additionally, for minor offenses, prosecutors may elect to
devote court resources to more serious cases that present
a danger to public safety. Some referrals are for a single
charge, though it is common for referrals to include
multiple charges. If all charges associated with a
referral are non-filed or receive a nolle prosequi, then
the youth does not receive any consequences or treatment
resulting from that referral. There is considerable
variation between circuits with regard to the percentage
of referrals that contain serious charges that result in
non-files or nolle prosequi. Statewide, 22% of referrals
involving at least one felony charge resulted in non-files
or nolle prosequi; judicial Circuits 1 and 10 had the
smallest percentage at 6% and Circuit 9 had the highest
percentage at 42%. Statewide, 18% of referrals that
involved a firearm charge resulted in non-files or nolle
prosequi; again, Circuits 1 (2%) and 10 (3%) had the
lowest percentage and Circuit 9 (29%) had the highest
percentage. Statewide, 21% of referrals that involved a
violent felony resulted in non-files or nolle prosequi;
Circuits 2 (2%) and 10 (5%) had the lowest percentage of
referrals dropped and Circuit 9 (41%) had the highest
percentage dropped.
|
Source: Florida Department of Juvenile Justice
|
|
This report presents the results of a rigorous evaluation
of Restoring Promise, an initiative that creates prison
housing units grounded in human dignity for young adults,
ages 18 to 25, that operate with re-trained staff, trained
mentors who are older adults serving long- or
life-sentences, and developmentally appropriate
activities, workshops, and opportunities for young adults.
The evaluation reflects two studies: the first is a study
of Restoring Promise in partnership with the South
Carolina Department of Corrections and the second is a
study of Restoring Promise across five housing units in
partnership with three corrections agencies. The first
study utilizes a randomized controlled trial to understand
whether and by how much Restoring Promise reduces young
adults’ incidences of violence and misconduct, comparing
outcomes for two groups of young adults who applied to
live on a Restoring Promise housing unit. The second study
of Restoring Promise across the five housing units
compares responses to the Restoring Promise Prison Culture
Survey from young adults incarcerated in three different
corrections agencies, living across five Restoring Process
housing units in Connecticut, South Carolina, and
Massachusetts. Findings showed that the results of the
randomized controlled trial are potentially applicable to
all young adults; the approach that Restoring Promise uses
has several fundamental components that are consistent
across locations; and young adults and staff report
similarly positive experiences, regardless of location,
due to prison culture changes. The finding that changing
the prison culture led to a reduction in violence fills a
gap in the field and provides evidence to support a new,
replicable model for improving safety in correctional
settings.
|
Source: U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Justice
Programs
|
|
The Second Chance Pell Experimental Sites Initiative
(SCP), launched by the U.S. Department of Education in
2015, provides need-based Pell Grants to people in state
and federal prisons. Federal Pell Grants for educational
expenses are awarded to undergraduate students who display
exceptional financial need and have not earned a
bachelor's, graduate, or professional degree. This
initiative examines whether expanding access to financial
aid increases incarcerated adults’ participation in
postsecondary educational opportunities. This program
gives invited colleges the opportunity to provide
credentialed college education programs within state and
federal prisons using federal aid for incarcerated
students who qualify. In 2016, the U.S. Department of
Education invited 67 colleges in 28 states, and in 2020,
it expanded SCP to include a total of 130 colleges from 42
states and Washington, DC. In 2022, SCP expanded again to
include a total of 200 colleges in 48 states, Washington,
DC, and Puerto Rico. The authors found that nearly 41,000
students participated in postsecondary education funded
through Second Chance Pell between 2016 and 2022. Programs
in Texas (6,333), Ohio (4,383), and Arkansas (3,264) have
enrolled the highest number of students; Florida falls in
the middle with 494 students enrolled. Students in prison
earned 11,966 credentials: bachelor’s degrees (6%),
associate’s degrees (48%), and certificates or
postsecondary diplomas (46%). Racial and gender
disparities persist in both enrollments and completions,
with the most pronounced disparities existing among
Hispanic/Latino students. More than one-third of colleges
(36%) included people who were legally, economically, or
familially affected in a negative way by the criminal
justice system in their faculty, staff, or administration.
The authors noted that access to educational opportunities
in prison has significant and meaningful benefits for
incarcerated people, their communities, and the public at
large, including personal and community development, job
training, racial equity, public safety, safety inside
prisons, and government savings.
|
Source: Vera Institute of Justice
|
|
|
In the face of enrollment declines and competing education
and workforce priorities, the need has never been greater
for clarity in our training and workforce systems and
alignment in education to employment pathways. Recently,
state leaders have begun aligning skills and competencies
in credential programs with workforce and economic needs,
which supports a growing emphasis on skills-based hiring.
There are almost 1 million credentials in the United
States, but there is little consistency in how information
about those credentials is collected and communicated.
State leaders continue to have questions about quality,
education and industry partnerships, and barriers in
training and workforce pathways. Policymakers have several
levers available to address these challenges and advance
credential transparency (which is defined as essential
information about credentials — including associated
skills and competencies — that is public, easily
accessible, and actionable) through legislation,
regulatory changes, executive orders, system policy or
other task forces and commissions. This report includes
state examples for three priority areas: 1. Data capacity;
2. Governance; and 3. Funding. Florida is highlighted in
the area of data capacity, specifically for providing
clear legislative direction for the collection of
informative workforce and credential data. The state’s
Reimagining Education and Career Help Act includes
components related to data collection and sharing that
facilitate state credential efforts. The act requires
facilitation and collection of data on non-degree and
degree credentials of value, identified by a Credentials
Review Committee, and to verify the validity of data
collected for federal and state compliance.
|
Source: Education Commission of the States
|
|
This report examines the relative effectiveness of two
teacher support models—a mixed-mode professional
development delivery model that aims to reduce costs
through a combination of in-person and virtual teacher
coaching, and the tested, resource-intensive, face-to-face
delivery model—in creating robust implementations of the
Assessment-to-Instruction (A2i) Professional Support
System and improvements in student literacy achievement.
Fifty-nine schools in 20 school districts were randomly
assigned either to a group of 30 schools that received the
mixed-mode model or to a group of 29 schools that received
the face-to-face model for three school years (2018–2019
to 2020–2021). Comparing student and teacher experiences
in the two sets of schools measures the relative
effectiveness of the two models. If both models are
implemented adequately, a finding of no difference in the
effects of the two models would indicate that they are
equally effective approaches to implementing A2i. The
authors noted that the two professional development models
had been in place for less than two school years when the
COVID-19 pandemic began in March 2020; in both models,
teachers did not fully utilize the A2i technology and had
difficulty differentiating instruction based on
A2i-generated recommendations. During the second half of
the implementation period, in-person coaching was not
possible due to pandemic-related school disruptions.
Teachers in both models reduced their use of A2i
components and differentiated small-group instruction.
Across all three study years, student achievement in
reading was similar in mixed-mode and face-to-face
schools, and about 50% of the third-graders in the study
were reading at or above proficiency level as defined by
state or district standards at the end of the evaluation.
However, because A2i was not fully implemented over the
study period, these results do not reflect the actual
relative effectiveness of the two professional development
models.
|
Source: MDRC
|
|
This brief describes the broad purposes of the federal
Higher Education Emergency Relief (HEER) funds as
indicated by Congress and the U.S. Department of
Education, and it provides a first look at how much
funding was awarded to and spent by the nation’s community
colleges between March 2020 and February 28, 2023. Over
$25 billion in HEER funding was awarded to community
colleges during the COVID-19 pandemic. HEER funds were
intended to serve two main purposes: (1) to provide
emergency aid directly to students facing financial
challenges during the COVID-19 pandemic and (2) to ensure
that institutions of higher education could continue
serving students in the midst of unforeseen disruptions.
Funds were designated in three categories: student aid,
institutional aid, and other aid. At the time of this
analysis, most community colleges had spent the great
majority of their HEER funds, including nearly all of
their allotment for student aid. Of the total funding
awarded, $22.4 billion (87%), or an average of $23 million
per institution, has been spent. Nearly 74% of the $3.4
billion in unspent funds is remaining institutional aid.
Where there are unspent funds, they are usually designated
for institutional and other aid. Student aid, which was
provided directly to students in the form of emergency
financial aid, totaled $10.1 billion and ranged from
$124,240 to $637 million per institution. Student aid
comprised 39% of total aid awarded and was the most
quickly spent. As of February 2023, 97% of student aid,
averaging $10 million per institution, has been spent.
|
Source: Community College Research Center
|
|
|
an understanding that hiring and retention have been
challenging for many industries, including the transit
industry, many agencies have recently made changes to
attempt to attract and retain more talented and diverse
individuals. In an effort to understand what is being
done, what is working, and what still needs to be solved,
the research team surveyed transit agencies throughout the
state. This whitepaper also includes six case study sites
from Florida transit agencies that were selected due to a
variety of characteristics, including their cumulative
representativeness of vacancies in every department and
the various partnerships and implemented service changes
that they mentioned in their survey responses. One
additional non-Florida transit agency was interviewed as a
case study due to their defined success in the use of
online job advertisements to attract new applicants.
Agencies responding to the survey reported providing
various types of transit services such as paratransit,
fixed route, in-house maintenance, Medicaid services, and
more. Paratransit services are the most common type of
service provided by survey respondents, followed by fixed
route.
|
Source: Center for Urban Transportation Research
|
|
This report offers a comprehensive look at state and
national trends in pedestrian deaths in 2022. It presents
pedestrian fatality projections for all of 2022 based on
preliminary data provided by the states, an in-depth
analysis of recently released 2021 pedestrian fatality
data from the National Highway Traffic Safety
Administration’s Fatality Analysis Reporting System and a
review of strategies to reduce pedestrian crashes,
injuries and deaths. The report projects that drivers
struck and killed at least 7,508 people walking in 2022 –
the highest number since 1981 and an average of 20 deaths
every day. Furthermore, pedestrian deaths rose 77% between
2010 and 2021, compared to a 25% rise in all other traffic
fatalities. The report also includes examples of state-
and community-level efforts to better understand the
factors that contribute to pedestrian crashes and
fatalities and how to prevent them from happening in the
future.
|
Source: Governors Highway Safety Association
|
|
This study uses comprehensive longitudinal data on total
household spending from a survey that is representative of
the older U.S. population to estimate the trajectories of
spending after age 65. Based on data spanning the period
2005-2019, real spending declined for both single and
coupled households after age 65 at annual rates of about
1.7% and 2.4%, respectively. Stratification by wealth
holdings observed at or closely following age 65 showed
sizeable variation in spending levels by wealth quartile,
but little variation in rates of change in spending. The
fact that spending declines broadly, including among those
in the highest wealth quartile, suggests that the decline
may not be related to economic position. This view is
supported by an analysis of budget shares which show
increases with age in the budget share for gifts and
donations which suggests that economic position on average
does not deteriorate with age, even as spending declines.
|
Source: RAND Corporation
|
|
|
Deaths due to suicide and homicide, often referred to
collectively as violent deaths, have been a leading cause
of premature death to people aged 10–24 in the United
States. A previous version of this report with data
through 2017 showed that suicide and homicide rates for
people aged 10–24 were trending upward. This report
updates the previous report using the most recent data
from the National Vital Statistics System and presents
trends from 2001 through 2021 in suicide and homicide
rates for people aged 10–24 and for age groups 10–14,
15–19, and 20–24. Key findings include that suicide rates
for people aged 10–24 increased from 2007 through 2021
(from 6.8 deaths per 100,000 to 11.0), while homicide
rates declined from 2006 through 2014, and then increased
through 2021. For people aged 10–14, the suicide rate
tripled from 2007 through 2018 (from 0.9 to 2.9), and then
did not change significantly through 2021, while the
homicide rate doubled from 2016 through 2021. For people
aged 15–19, the suicide rate increased from 2009 through
2017, and the homicide rate decreased from 2006 through
2013 but then increased through 2021, surpassing the
suicide rate in 2020. For people aged 20–24, the suicide
rate increased over the entire period, while the homicide
rate increased from 2014 through 2020 and remained
unchanged in 2021.
|
Source: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services,
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
|
|
Where people live may impact their ability to access
health care services and for those with disabilities or
who require specialized care that entails more frequent
attention and medical visits, location can play an even
more significant role.. Examining disability rates across
geography reveals notable differences between urban and
rural areas, and regions. In 2021, nearly 42.5 million
people (13%) among the civilian non-institutionalized
population in the United States had a disability,
according to the American Community Survey 1-year
estimates. Rural residents — less than 20% of the U.S.
population — were more likely (14.7%) than their urban
counterparts to experience disability. Rural communities
may be more geographically isolated and typically have
more limited transportation and access to clinics and
hospitals than urban areas. As a result, coordination of
care for those with disabilities may be more difficult for
rural residents due to these geographic and transportation
barriers. In 2021, the South had the nation’s highest
rates of disability (13.8%), followed by the Midwest
(13.1%), the Northeast (12.3%), and the West (12.1%).
Regional disability rates may differ for a variety of
reasons. For example, disability is often associated with
age, so regions that contain states with a higher
proportion of the population age 65 and over may be more
likely to report higher rates of disability. Many states
in the South are part of what is known as the Stroke Belt,
defined by the National Heart Lung and Blood Institute as
a cluster of states (including Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia,
Indiana, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina,
South Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia) that have a higher
incidence of stroke than the rest of the country. Although
the South and the Midwest had the nation’s highest overall
disability rates in 2021, the South had the largest
differences in disability rates by urban/rural residence
and the Midwest had the smallest urban/rural differences
in disability rates.
|
Source: U.S. Department of Commerce, Census Bureau
|
|
In the 18 months between April 2021 and October 2022,
direct care staffing declined across Florida’s more than
700 nursing homes. The number of nursing staff members
providing direct care dropped from an average of more than
3.9 hours per resident per day to 3.6. Multiple factors
play into this decline, including the workforce shortage
that has plagued many sectors of the economy. Legislative
changes that took effect in April 2022 made significant
changes in minimum staffing requirements. Data from the
federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS)
reveal how staffing changed before and after the 2022
legislation. Overall, the data for October 2022 show that
while nurse staffing declined in the 18-month study
period, the late 2022 levels met Florida’s pre-April 2022
requirement to provide 3.6 hours of nursing care to each
resident per day. It is worth noting, however, that the
numbers represent a statewide average, suggesting that
some nursing homes were above this minimum requirement,
and some were below. Coordinated efforts are needed to
attract more people into the long-term care workforce,
from CNAs to social workers to therapists to RNs. Several
recommendations are offered in the areas of policy
development, research, workforce education, and funding
opportunities.
|
Source: AARP Florida
|
N O T E : An online subscription may be required to view some items.
|
|
|
|
OPPAGA is currently accepting applications for a part-time, academic year
Graduate Student Position.
OPPAGA is an ideal setting for gaining hands-on experience in policy analysis
and working on a wide range of issues of interest to the Florida Legislature.
OPPAGA provides an opportunity to work in a legislative policy research offices
with a highly qualified, multidisciplinary staff.
|
|
|
|
Government Program Summaries (GPS) is a free resource for legislators and the public that provides descriptive information on over 200 state government programs. To provide fiscal data, GPS links to Transparency
Florida, the Legislature's website that includes continually updated information on the state's operating budget and daily expenditures by state agencies.
|
A publication of the Florida Legislature's Office of Program Policy Analysis and Government Accountability.
Click here to subscribe to this publication.
As a joint legislative unit, OPPAGA works with both the
Senate and the House of Representatives to conduct
objective research, program reviews, and contract
management for the Florida Legislature.
PolicyNotes, published every Friday, features reports, articles, and websites with timely information of interest to policymakers and researchers. Any opinions, findings, conclusions, or recommendations
expressed by third parties as reported in this publication are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect OPPAGA's views.
Permission is granted to make and distribute verbatim copies of
PolicyNotes provided that this section is preserved on all copies.
|
|